With all the talk about NAFTA recently, particularly in the Ohio Democratic primary run up, it seems the right time to talk about why this discussion is largely moot.
Leapfrog Effect nations grow rapidly but they often start from a position significantly under developed compared to the U.S., Europe, Japan, and other Innovation Nations. It's reasonable to expect that they won't have processes and procedures in place to provide the kinds of environmental and safety protections we take for granted.
The thing is, they can Leapfrog to those standards just like they can for technology. Innovation Nations, like the U.S. already have developed, tested, and refined solutions to many of these issues. Of course, over the years we've gotten better at it so, for example, modern bridges are better built than the ones we built thirty years ago. A Leapfrog Nation can start building using the best of these standards that they can afford and at 8% growth, each year they can bump up a notch.
Implementation of new regulations normally comes in response to a problem. Recently we've seen China suffering from a major bridge collapse, toxic chemical spills that cut water supplies to millions, mine safety issues, air pollution concerns raised by the upcoming Olympic games in Beijing, and a strong awareness of global warming and other ecological issues.
China is responding to these issues aggressively and over the next decades the effectiveness of regulations in China may well exceed that of the Innovation Nations due to the Leapfrog Effect.
If either of the current Democratic contenders wins this Fall and follows through on promises to renegotiate NAFTA don't be surprised if they win concessions to have Mexico agree to what it has already done to improve, making this whole issue not much more than politics without real substance.
Good jobs can be found for workers in Ohio and throughout the U.S. but those aren't the jobs we're losing to productivity improvements and lower labor costs. They are the skilled work that capable Americans do well. Jobs in energy and natural resource management technologies, technologies that Leapfrog and Innovation Nations alike need.
All of the current Presidential candidates have plans for "green-collar" jobs. I wholeheartedly support that idea. Now what is needed is development of the green marketplace. It's not just the domestic and developed world marketplace that these "green-collar" workers should be serving, it's the Leapfrog Effect nations who need green technology and products that they can afford and use.
Developed (Innovation Nations) and developing (Leapfrog Effect Nations) have differing needs for green products and we should be marketing and developing solutions that meet both needs. Renewable energy production demonstrates my point. To be viable in the Innovation Nations it must be highly reliable, available 24/7/365, and cost effective, or at least close to cost effective. Leapfrog Effect Nations often don't even have electricity in many locations. Less reliable time-of-day availability, something Innovation Nations would never accept, is still a huge upgrade for Leapfrog Nations.
Take, for example, a solar electric solution. Without costly storage it only produces electricity during the day. Day workers in a factory could take advantage of the electricity to use electrically driven machinery, have adequate lighting, and take advantage of other more modern manufacturing tools and techniques.
With financial success generated by the increased productivity the factory can invest in electric storage technology and additional generating capacity to add another work shift, and eventually, a third.
Continuing success would likely result in increased pay for workers, and an increased demand by them for electricity in their homes.
I think you can see the path from here. Each increase in productivity allows for an increase in the standard of living and an increase in the demand for goods and services that goes along with that standard. In the Leapfrog Effect Nations that growth rate can be very rapid indeed.
If we want all the "green-collar" jobs, we need to work equally hard to develop these Leapfrog Effect marketplaces for our worker's products. If we don't someone else will.
Let's go feed some frogs.